From Allied to Alienated
Ayatollah Sayed Mortada Al-Qazwini should be
one of America's best friends in Iraq.
A tall, turbaned man with a candid manner and commanding presence,
Al-Qazwini was one of the first Shiite Muslim religious scholars to
speak out against Saddam Hussein. He lost 15 relatives to Hussein's
brutality, and in 1971 he fled Iraq to escape a death sentence.
He settled in Diamond Bar and built Shiite religious, cultural and
educational centers in Pomona, Irvine, San Diego and Detroit over the
next 18 years. All the while, he marveled at the freedom he enjoyed to
practice the faith of his persecuted sect. After U.S. forces toppled
Hussein a year ago, Al-Qazwini was ecstatic and went home to help.
"Ninety-nine percent of the people are so happy that Saddam has been put
down. The coalition forces saved us," he said then.
Now, a year after his emotional homecoming, Al-Qazwini, 75, is deeply
disillusioned. U.S. forces have worn out their welcome by failing to
fulfill their promises for democracy, political empowerment and
reconstruction, the ayatollah said. He wants them to leave Iraq as soon
Prices have soared, the streets are filled with trash, gasoline lines
remain long and blackouts are still common, he said in a recent
interview at his son's home in Rowland Heights.
"The coalition forces are not doing anything about it," he fumed. "With
all their power and authority, they're staying silent.
"If the U.S. doesn't improve the situation soon, it's possible that
powerful Shia scholars might tell people to resist," Al-Qazwini said.
"Right now the Shias are choosing to cooperate, but patience has a
Al-Qazwini represents a window into the heart of Iraqi aspirations — and
His disillusionment developed gradually. In an interview in September,
after he had returned from an initial trip to Iraq, Al-Qazwini was still
awed by the liberation of his homeland. He was tearful about the miracle
that U.S. forces had delivered to him: a chance to set foot again on the
sacred soil of Karbala, a southern Iraqi city of more than 1 million
people that is home to the holy shrine of Imam Hussein.
For 300 years, his family members had preached and taught in Karbala.
During the 20th century, they lived in a home next to the Imam Hussein
shrine. During his exile, Al-Qazwini always carried a small cake of
Karbala's holy soil in his pocket. It was a reminder of his heritage and
the martyrdom of Imam Hussein, whom Shiites revere.
Karbala was more than a place; it was a spiritual touchstone where
Al-Qazwini felt in direct commune with his beloved imam and where he
claims to have received healing miracles. So it was no surprise that the
moment Saddam Hussein's regime fell, Al-Qazwini insisted on returning,
telling his wary sons that he would buy a rug and sleep in the shrine if
"The first time I saw the dome of Imam Hussein's shrine, I could not
control myself," he said, his voice cracking and eyes filling with
tears. "I began to talk to him: 'Oh, Imam Hussein, I am your son. I have
come from far away to guide my people and country. Please help me.' "
Word soon spread that the ayatollah had returned home. Crowds surrounded
him, pulling at his clothes, kissing his forehead, demanding to know
where he had been, pleading for speeches and sermons.
The people, he said, were hungry for spiritual teachings, which had been
severely repressed under Hussein.
For the last year in Karbala, Al-Qazwini said, he has delivered his
teachings twice daily — after noon and sunset prayers — at the shrine.
He started classes on Islamic law and culture, revitalizing a private
seminary that had lain dormant during the Hussein years.
According to Al-Qazwini's son, Moustafa, the family established an
orphanage to serve 2,000 children. With friends, the Al-Qazwinis opened
a university aimed at giving Shiites the higher education they had often
been denied during Hussein's regime; already, 600 students have
They dreamed of bigger ventures. The most urgent was a second hospital
for the city. In September, the son said they had begun negotiating with
potential donors in the Persian Gulf, grant makers in the U.S.
government and Iraqi doctors.
"This is the least we can do to give back to Iraq," Moustafa said then.
"Our horizons have been broadened in America, where we've seen so many
charities and philanthropic institutions. We thought, why not bring them
back to Iraq?"
His father added: "This is what brings people to religion — not just
lectures and sermons and admonishing people to do right. It's when they
see religion serving their basic needs that they become more
compassionate in return."
Six months later, the ayatollah was back in Southern California for a
family visit and was recovering from heart bypass surgery. But it was
not his health that made him downcast.
His ebullience seemed gone as he plunged into the litany of grievances
he had heard from his congregants in Karbala: escalating crime, massive
unemployment, disrespectful treatment by U.S. forces.
Chaos has derailed the hospital plans, because security could not be
guaranteed for potential donors and doctors. It has also discouraged
many Iraqi Americans, an important source of money and expertise, from
"Dreams have been shattered, unfortunately," said Moustafa, 42, who
often acts as his father's spokesman. "Nothing has been improved.
Nothing! Yet we hear of Halliburton receiving multimillion-dollar
contracts and we wonder where the money is going. The mistrust of Iraqis
toward Americans is evolving and increasing."
American promises of democracy also have fallen short, the ayatollah
said. He said the U.S. position against an Iraqi constitution based on
the Islamic law of Sharia "angered and insulted" many Iraqis.
The ayatollah supports a middle course between an Iranian-style
theocracy and the U.S. model of separation of church and state. He
believes that religious scholars should not hold office but should offer
guidance to policymakers. He also believes that the nation's laws, if
not based solely on Sharia, must not conflict with it.
"The majority of people want a government that conforms with Islam,"
Provisions in the interim constitution that in effect would allow
minority groups to veto laws favored by the Shiite majority would again
deprive Shiites of their rightful leadership role, the Al-Qazwinis said.
Iraqis must be allowed direct elections and the freedom to install the
first Shiite government in the Arab world, despite the misgivings of
neighboring Sunni Muslim countries, they said.
Some Iraqi Americans remain more positive about America's effect on
their country. But asked whether the Iraqi people are happier today than
before the war, the ayatollah replied, "No."
"The fear of religious persecution has been lifted," he said, "but
people feel they are still unsafe and at any time their lives can be
"The U.S. needs to realize that they shouldn't take the Shiite majority
for granted," he said. "It's within their power to put up resistance if
Al-Qazwini speaks from family experience. His father participated in the
1920 revolt against the British occupation that was largely led by
Shiites from Karbala and Najaf.
By the time he was 30, Sayed Mortada Al-Qazwini already was quarrelling
with Iraq's secular leaders, opposing the communist alliances of Iraqi
ruler Abdel Karim Qasim, an army officer who gained power in 1958.
In one exchange, Al-Qazwini said, he got into a heated argument with
Qasim over a new law giving equal inheritance rights to women and men.
The law violated Islamic tenets that give men twice as much, in keeping
with their legal responsibility to provide for women, the ayatollah
When Qasim tried to placate him with offers of financial support,
Al-Qazwini said, he stormed out, headed to the mosque and told the crowd
that the Iraqi ruler had just tried to bribe him. He was arrested a few
It would be the first of several arrests. There would be two years of
exile — in Zaho, a Kurdish region near the Turkish border, and Tikrit,
Saddam Hussein's Sunni stronghold. Undaunted, Al-Qazwini directed his
criticism at Hussein after the Baath Party took control in 1968 and
continued to persecute Shiites.
By then, Al-Qazwini had become an ayatollah, Arabic for "sign of God,"
with authority to issue religious rulings, establish seminaries, teach
The Shiite sect bestows the office on religious scholars who have taught
— often for 15 to 20 years — and have been certified as competent by a
grand ayatollah. Al-Qazwini is one of about 200 ayatollahs in the Shiite
Muslim world today. His followers are mainly in Karbala, the Persian
Gulf states and the United States.
In 1971, Al-Qazwini said, he was tipped off by the governor of Karbala
that Hussein's forces planned to arrest and execute him. That night, the
ayatollah told his family that they were going on a vacation. Only after
leaving the country did he explain the real reason for the flight.
He continued to rail against Hussein. In 1980, when the family was
living in Kuwait, the Iraqi dictator arrested Al-Qazwini's father in
Karbala. Al-Qazwini says Hussein also sent assassins after him; they
shot and missed. The next day, Al-Qazwini fled to Iran. Later he moved
to London and in 1986 decided to make the United States his home.
It was here that Al-Qazwini found the freedom he had long dreamed of. At
his urging, four of his nine children have followed his lead and started
Ali directs the Assidiq Foundation in Pomona, Moustafa heads the
Irvine-based Islamic Educational Center of Orange County, Muhammad runs
a mosque in San Diego and Hassan directs a center in Detroit. The sons
are also active in American Muslim affairs, a new Shiite national
organization and numerous interfaith groups.
"My father would often say, 'In this country, we were able to establish
schools and convey the message of Islam and Shiism, even to non-Muslims,
whereas in Muslim countries we were not able to do that,' " Ali said.
"He was so happy."
Another son, Jafar, said a 1991 incident deepened his father's emotional
connection to America. He arrived at Los Angeles International Airport
from a visit to the Mideast, and an immigration officer asked where he
The ayatollah said, "I was home."
"This is your home," the officer replied.
"Excuse me?" the ayatollah said.
"This is your home," the officer repeated.
When he picked up his father at the airport, Jafar said, the ayatollah
was in tears.
"After living in exile, moving from one country to another for fear of
assassination, to hear someone in America tell him that this was his
home deeply touched him," Jafar said.
It pains the ayatollah now to see such hostility toward the U.S. forces
that once symbolized freedom.
"In those first days, everyone was overwhelmed with celebration and
joy," Al-Qazwini said. "But one incident after another took the hope